Talk:ICA Responce on USLSSR

Stop, just stop

1) Unite under the red banner is what is meant, meaning we put aside our differences for a common goal.

2) I do not propose a new nation but an international union very much like the OAM, in short a forum for the left wing in the community.

3) We ourselves are patriotic and wouldn't sign our selves over to a "super state" of united socialist states

4) Learn to spell, "aspect from a communist?"

5) Well in the Socialism we preach in the USLSSR, a person is given by the state: A home of adequate size, all the food they need to live with, running water, electricity and gas. We provide this by taking a proportion of everyone’s wages (first we take all private property into the care of the state) and using this money we give everything a person needs to live. After we have taken the same percentage from every person’s wages, what is left over is for the earner to use as he/she wishes to buy normal consumer goods.

6) If capitalism runs the world then why could China (a communist state) recall its loans to the capitalist superpower (who invade others in the name of freedom and capitalism) and bankrupt them totally?

7) Lets take the example of charity, if we are so very greedy then why do we give our things/time away for free?

8) Where did I say I wanted to eliminate you? Please enlighten me.

9) Again see point number 2

10) Well I'd like to put the point to you. Where did the middle and upper classes (bourgeoisie) come from? Did they just materialise? No they came from the working classes, so do not tell me that the working class only take and do not aspire to greater things.

11) Give me one example of pure Marxism being implemented and failing. You cannot. It hasn't been done. Now you will be sitting at your desk, or in bed and be saying "look at the USSR" well I can simply say to you that they were not Marxists when they collapsed or at all, they used adapted systems. To compound my point even more we can certainly say at the collapse of the USSR they weren’t communist.

If I have missed anything out don’t hasten to tell me. President Whitmarsh 23:44, August 20, 2010 (UTC)

Hear! Hear! Anything worth wild that I have to say has already been perfectly stated by Herr Whitmarsh. Thank you sir! James Wilary of the People's reformed States Republic 02:51, August 21, 2010 (UTC)

Please, refrain from this. Respect the opinions of the Communist nations and stop trying to put them in a bad light to further your own agenda. Communism has its flaws, and the Empire is by no means a socialist country, but do away with this nonsensical banter. HolySalanianEmpire 03:52, August 21, 2010 (UTC)

I find it interesting that whenever a communist nation attacks capitalism, they are never attacked themselves, and that when a capitalist organisation attacks communism, everyone rips on them. This makes no sense.

Secundomia ^{(talk),(Contributions),(blog),(followed pages)} 17:30, August 21, 2010 (UTC)